A Comparison of Democratic and Totalitarian Political Systems: Outline
Title:
A Comparison of Democratic and Totalitarian Political Systems
Thesis: Democratic and totalitarian
political systems are both institutions of authority that demand active and
enthusiastic participation from its people; however; the key characteristics
that distinguish the two political systems are control of power, degree of participation
in politics, the rate of freedom and the economic system.
I.
A key distinguishing factors
between democratic and totalitarian regimes is the control of power whereby
democracies function by separation of powers whereas totalitarian regimes rely
on consolidation of powers.
A.
Democratic governments divide
their powers into three: the executive, judiciary, and legislature (Khan and
Muhammad, 2016).
B.
Totalitarian regimes centralize all their
power to a single person or a small group of people.
II.
A democratic regime is
characterized by political equality whereas a totalitarian government is
characterized by political inequality.
A.
Democracies typically pursue
laws that allow free formulation of political preferences and free competition
for political power through elections (Przeworski, Stokes, and Manin, 1999).
B.
Totalitarian regimes limit the
political participation in which their citizens can engage in political
activities.
III.
Another main difference between
a democratic government and a totalitarian one is the extent of freedom that
the government guarantees its citizens.
A.
In democracies, the state is
expected to protect and guarantee the individual rights and freedoms of its
citizens. Organzations such as Freedom House rank countries according to how democratic
they are (“Freedom in the World 2018”).
B.
Totalitarian regimes restrict
the freedoms of their citizens including freedom of the press, assembly and
freedom of speech.
IV.
Another difference between
democratic and totalitarian regimes is the mode of production.
A.
In most democratic societies, the economic
system is based on individualization, such that the economy is allowed to grow
without outside intervention (Tomasi, 2012).
B.
In totalitarian regimes, a
capitalist mode of production is usually preserved, but it often takes the
direction of monopoly capitalism whereby monopolization of the companies is
maximized and the competition in the market is reduced.
V.
Both democratic and totalitarian regimes
demand enthusiastic and active participation from its people.
A.
As much as totalitarian regimes
restrict the individual rights and freedom of their people, they can create not
only active but voluntary participation through ideology and propaganda (O'Shaughnessy,
2009; Sviličić and Maldini, 2013). Similarly, for a democracy to work, there
needs to be active participation of citizens.
VI.
Democratic and totalitarian
governments are also similar in the sense that they are both institutions of
authority, and therefore both have the potential to oppress people.
A.
As much as a democracy separates its powers, it is possible for a
majority of the citizens to elect a single party, who can then overtake and
corrupt the system of equality that should be typical of democracies.
B.
For instance, Azerbaijan has
been controlled by the Aliyev family and its circle of connections, making it
difficult to have a democracy whereby the all the citizens have political
equality (Sultanova, 2014).
References
Freedom in the World 2018. (2018, February 14). Retrieved April 05,
2018, from https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/freedom-world-2018
Gentile, E. (2004). Fascism, totalitarianism and political religion:
definitions and critical reflections on criticism of an interpretation. Totalitarian
Movements and Political Religions, 5(3), 326-375.
Khan, M. I., & Muhammad, A. (2016). An Evaluation of Separation
of Powers: A Case Study of Pakistan (2007-2013). South Asian Studies
(1026-678X), 31(1), 257-274.
O'Shaughnessy, N. (2009). Selling Hitler: propaganda and the Nazi
brand. Journal of Public Affairs (14723891), 9(1),
55-76.
Przeworski, A., Stokes, S. C., & Manin, B. (Eds.). (1999). Democracy,
accountability, and representation (Vol. 2). Cambridge University
Press.
Sultanova, S. (2014). Challenging the Aliyev Regime: Political
Opposition In Azerbaijan. Demokratizatsiya, 22(1),
15-37.
Sviličić, N., & Maldini, P. (2013). Visual Persuasion and
Politics: Ideology and Symbols of the Totalitarian Regimes’–Case Study: Hammer
and Sickle. Collegium antropologicum, 37(2), 569-582.
Tomasi, J. (2012). Free Market Fairness. Princeton:
Princeton University Press.
안녕하세요. Homeworkvan 입니다 :) 요즘 스케쥴이 바쁜 관계로 블로그에 신경을 못쓰고있네요. 어느정도 스케쥴 정리되는대로 다시 업데이트 하도록 하겠습니다! 감사합니다 :)
=========================================================
No comments:
Post a Comment